Introduction
The landscape of private debt is undergoing dynamic shifts, marked by a surge in real asset debt and risk-sharing initiatives. This market evolution is captured in data reported by Bloomberg, reflecting investor optimism about the future trajectory of private debt. However, beneath this optimism lie nuanced challenges, as highlighted by Moody’s cautionary outlook and concerns surrounding valuation uncertainties. As we delve into the complexities of this $1.7 trillion market, we explore the interplay between confidence and caution, navigating a terrain where opportunities coexist with potential risks.
Investor Sentiment: Bloomberg Survey Highlights Confidence in Private Debt Despite Short-Term Concerns
According to a Bloomberg survey, 43% of investors believe that private debt will outperform all other credit categories in the next 12 months. Furthermore, creditors view private debt as a tool to gather more information and secure greater guarantees in the event that the debt is not repaid. Other credit measures considered to perform well in the near future are high-yield bonds; in this case, 31% of investors interviewed by Bloomberg think so. While there are concerns about declining yields in direct lending in the near term, these prospects are overshadowed by a bearish outlook on government debt markets. In particular, this pessimistic view of public debt reflects expectations of non-payment by financial companies. In the long term, it seems that the majority of those interviewed, around 57%, see private debt as a safe haven in the event of any economic downturn. This positive view regarding public debt is based on its floating rate, which benefits investors when interest rates are high. Given the low trading volume, in the event of turbulence in the markets, the interest rate of private debt will be affected less, resulting in lower volatility.
Analysts expect private debt Assets Under Management (AUM) to surpass $1.7 trillion this year and reach $2.8 trillion by 2028. Noteworthy fund closures in 2024 include Arcmont’s €10 billion for direct lending in Europe and Benefit Street Partners’ $4.7 billion for direct lending in North America. However, early signs suggest a slowdown in the pace of fundraising.
Another concern among interviewees, however, is the difficulty in identifying the debtor’s repayment in a timely manner. Indeed, some investors fear that the private debt market may be a bubble ready to explode. Survey results show that some respondents think private debt credit margins will decline as public markets intensify competition. Another risk highlighted in the survey is the increased perception of a crisis in the commercial real estate (CRE) sector. In fact, around three-quarters of those interviewed predict that CRE stress will increase in the next 12 months, while half believe that this will mainly affect the banking sector. The remainder fear repercussions on various types of assets.
Moody’s Warning: Intensifying Competition and Stabilized Interest Rates Pose Challenges for Private Debt Market
Moody’s believes that the current success of private debt could encounter problems due to the recovery of the loan market, driven by increased competition between banks for significant deals. This competition has led to a decrease in yields of private debt, as indicated by data collected by Bloomberg. For example, a $3.3 billion private credit loan for the UK insurance broker Ardonagh Group Ltd. was priced at 475 basis points over a US reference rate, while Blackstone Inc. sought a $250 million loan for its planned acquisition of Rover Group at a similar pricing. In Europe, Iris Software secured a loan from private lenders at 5 percentage points over the UK benchmark, 75 basis points less than Adevinta’s record loan in November. A further decrease in the spread is also expected as banks and non-banks ensure that prices converge due to competition and stabilized interest rates.
Analysts have also observed that the liquidity premium and yields on private debt are under pressure as interest rates stabilize and competition increases. It has been observed that companies are attempting to refinance private operations in public markets to achieve interest savings. Moody’s found that many companies can save 200 to 300 basis points by choosing government debt over direct lending. PitchBook LCD data indicates that, so far this year, 21 companies have issued widely syndicated loans to refinance $8.3 billion in debt previously provided by direct lenders. These capital increases could lead to an expansion of regulation on the matter. Furthermore, the Federal Reserve has expressed concerns about the risks deriving from the concentration of large capital among a limited number of managers.
Private Credit Puzzle: Valuation Uncertainties and Growing Risks in the $1.7 Trillion Market
The rise of private credit funds, currently valued at $1 trillion, has raised doubts about its true market value and consequently the associated risks, especially in a period where central bank rate increases are putting corporate credit borrowers to the test. The initial appeal of private debt, linked to the stability on offer and promising returns, is now undergoing some change, as some private fund managers appear to resist valuation adjustments, creating inconsistency.
Regulators are paying attention to private markets due to the lack of consensus there and fears that this could hide troubled loans. The SEC has introduced regulations for external audits; however, the lack of regulation in foreign countries, other than the US, adds an additional challenge. Critics argue that this lack of clarity could lead to a reckoning, especially with rising interest rates impacting the riskiness of borrowers. Some believe that regulatory failures and investors’ desire to maintain stable valuations contribute to the opacity. A further risk brought to light is linked to the methodology for assessing the riskiness of companies in difficulty; in fact, many funds evaluate different assets with different methodologies, obtaining different results. All of this adds to the debate about whether the asset class actually reflects the risk associated with lending to risky businesses.
Conclusion
In summary, the private debt market reflects a dichotomy of optimism and caution. The Bloomberg survey highlights investor confidence, with a significant percentage anticipating private debt to outperform. However, Moody’s warning signals challenges arising from heightened competition. Concerns about identifying debtor repayments and potential market bubbles add a layer of caution.
Join ThePlatform to have full access to all analysis and content: https://www.theplatform.finance/registration/
Disclaimer: https://www.theplatform.finance/website-disclaimer/
