Together with…
Introduction
Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) are a type of structured credit product that repackages a pool of leveraged loans, typically corporate loans, into tranches with varying degrees of risk and return.
The intricate structure of CLOs introduces inherent risks stemming from the underlying loan portfolio and the securitization process itself. While offering potential rewards, these structured products demand a comprehensive understanding of the risks involved.
CLO Investors’ Exposure to Endogenous Risk
Endogenous risk refers to risks that originate from within a system, rather than from external factors. In the financial realm, these risks are inherently generated by the interactions and behaviours of market participants.
Unlike exogenous risks, which are imposed from outside the system, endogenous risks are cultivated within its framework. Along with many benefits, CLOs are complicated investments. Naturally, they also present a number of risks that investors should consider carefully. These include:
- Credit risk: While CLOs have historically enjoyed strong credit quality due to the senior secured status of leveraged loans, it’s important to keep in mind that leveraged loans carry inherent credit risk: They’re issued to below-investment-grade companies whose revenue streams are sensitive to fluctuations in the economic cycle.
- The Potential for Collateral Deterioration: If a CLO’s loans experience losses, cash flows are allocated to tranches in order of seniority. Depending on the severity of the losses, the value of the equity tranche could be wiped out and junior loan tranches could lose principal.
- Default of Servicer/Special Servicer: Servicer or special servicer defaults present significant risks to a CLO. Such events disrupt cash flow generation, impair loan administration, and increase credit risk due to potential deterioration in loan performance. Operational challenges and increased costs associated with transitioning to a new servicer can further impact the CLO’s performance.
- Non-Recourse and Not Guaranteed: Leveraged loans are senior obligations and, as such, generally have full recourse to the borrower and its assets in the event of default. A CLO, however, has recourse only to the principal and interest payments of the loans in the portfolio.
- Loan Prepayments: Leveraged loan borrowers may choose to prepay their loans in pieces or completely. While experienced CLO managers may anticipate prepayments, they’re nonetheless unpredictable. The size, timing, and frequency of prepayments could potentially disrupt cash flows and challenge managers’ ability to maximize portfolio value.
- Reputational Risk: Lenders who invest in a large amount of leveraged loans could face reputational risk if the leveraged loan market experiences a downturn. This is because investors may come to view the lender as being too risky.
- Trading Illiquidity: CLOs generally enjoy healthy trading liquidity, but that could change very quickly if market conditions turn. A prime example is the financial crisis when trading activity for even the most liquid debt instruments slowed to a trickle.
- The Timing of Issuance: While market conditions could be strong when a CLO is issued, they might not be during its reinvestment period. That’s what happened to the 2003 vintages, whose reinvestment period coincided with the onset of the financial crisis and its resulting drop-off in trading volume.
- Manager Performance: The historical performance of CLO managers encompasses a wide spectrum of returns, underscoring the importance of choosing seasoned managers with solid long-term track records.
- Spread Duration: While interest rate duration is low due to the floating-rate nature of CLO tranches (indexed off three-month Libor, Euribor, or SOFR), spread duration is a consideration that should be taken into account. Due to a typical reinvestment period of four to five years, the spread duration is usually between 3.5 and seven years. The higher up the capital stack, the lower the spread duration, as each CLO is redeemed sequentially, making the lower-rated tranches longer in spread duration.
- Currency Risk: Lenders who invest in leveraged loans that are denominated in a foreign currency are also exposed to currency risk. This means that the value of their investment could decline if the exchange rate between the foreign currency and the lender’s home currency moves against them.
CLICK HERE TO GET MORE INFORMATION
Risk Mitigation
Mitigating endogenous risks, arising from within the CLO market itself, require specific strategies. While these risks can be complex, investors can implement several measures to protect their investments.
- Understanding CLOs– Investors should have a clear understanding of CLO structures, risks, and rewards.
- Risk Tolerance Assessment- Investors should assess their risk tolerance before investing in CLOs.
- Diversified Portfolio- CLO investments should be part of a diversified portfolio.
- Clear Communication- CLO managers should provide clear and transparent information about the fund’s investment strategy, risks, and performance.
- Regular Reporting- Regular reporting on the fund’s performance and risk metrics can help investors monitor their investments.
By implementing these strategies, investors can significantly reduce their exposure to endogenous risks within the CLO market. It’s essential to remember that while these measures can help mitigate risks, they do not guarantee against losses.
Conclusion
CLOs, while offering attractive returns, are subject to a complex interplay of endogenous and exogenous risks, which we will explore later in our next paper.
Understanding these risks is paramount for investors and managers alike. From credit and market risks to operational and systemic challenges, the CLO landscape is dynamic and requires vigilant monitoring. Diversification, robust risk management practices, and a deep understanding of the underlying assets are essential for mitigating these risks and maximizing investment opportunities.
Disclaimer
Index:
Data Room AccessData room access is available only for accredited and institutional investors due to FCA permissions.
To gain access, click and fill out the following form. Our compliance team will grant you access within 24 hours.
